Guide to decide
Custom or existing tool: how to decide
Key takeaways: An existing tool is usually the best way to start if your way of working is standard. A custom product pays off when your way of working is what sets you apart, or when the tool forces workarounds. The decision should compare total cost, not just the starting price.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know whether I need something custom yet?
If you spend hours each week moving data between tools or adapting your way of working to theirs, it is probably worth studying.
Can you keep what I already use and improve it?
Sometimes yes: we connect the tools you already use with an automation, without replacing them.
What if I get it wrong?
That is why we start with a definition and a prototype you approve before we build, and the contract includes adjustments after delivery.
When an existing tool is enough
- Your process is the usual one in your industry and the tool covers it well.
- You are just starting and do not yet know what you need.
- You have few users and the monthly fee is small.
- You do not need clients to see your brand, only the tool's.
In those cases, starting there is a good decision. You also do not have to pick one path: sometimes an existing tool for the standard parts and something custom only for what sets you apart is the best mix.
When a custom product pays off
- You pay for several tools and connect them by hand with copy and paste.
- Your way of working is what makes you different and no tool respects it.
- You want clients to see your brand and their own space, not another company's.
- The per-user fee grows with your business and over time outweighs owning something.
- You want control of your data and the ability to export it, with less risk of someone else changing their terms.
Six criteria to compare
| Criterion | Existing tool | Custom product |
|---|---|---|
| Functional fit | Covers the usual; specifics are handled with workarounds or not at all | Designed around your process, within the agreed scope |
| Initial investment | Low or none: you subscribe and configure | Higher: definition, design and development; quoted according to scope |
| Recurring costs | Monthly fee, which usually grows with users and features | Hosting, third-party services and optional maintenance, as agreed |
| Maintenance | Done by the vendor, on its schedule and with its changes | Agreed with you: what is fixed, what is improved and on what timeframes, in the proposal |
| Data export | Depends on the vendor and the plan | Defined at the start; data sits in accounts in your name |
| Technical dependence | On the vendor and its terms | On whoever maintains it; that is why it is delivered documented and with accounts in your name |
Indicative example: total cost over 2 years
This is an example with assumed figures, to show how to reason. They are not Waves prices or a market average. Assumptions: the tool charges €25 per user per month and costs €500 to set up; the custom product has an initial investment of €6,900, assumed maintenance of €79 a month and third-party services (hosting, messaging and the like) of €20 a month with 8 users and €45 a month with 25 users; all over 24 months and without discounts.
Formulas: tool = set-up + users x fee x 24. Custom = initial investment + (maintenance + third-party services) x 24.
| Item (24 months) | Tool, 8 users | Custom, 8 users | Tool, 25 users | Custom, 25 users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initial investment | €500 | €6,900 | €500 | €6,900 |
| Per-user fees | 8 x €25 x 24 = €4,800 | €0 | 25 x €25 x 24 = €15,000 | €0 |
| Maintenance | Included in the fee | €79 x 24 = €1,896 | Included in the fee | €79 x 24 = €1,896 |
| Third-party services | Included in the fee | €20 x 24 = €480 | Included in the fee | €45 x 24 = €1,080 |
| Total over 2 years | €5,300 | €9,276 | €15,500 | €9,876 |
With 8 users the tool is cheaper. With 25, the tool total exceeds the custom product total, although the custom product also grows (in the example, through third-party services). There is no number of users that works for every case: it depends on the real fee, on what the product costs and on how much its services grow. And if the tool does not fit your process, there is a cost the table does not show: the time lost on workarounds. That is why we work it out with your real figures.
A middle path
Often the best option is a step in between: a custom dashboard, or an AI automation that links the tools you already use. If you already know you want an app, see how much a custom app costs.
Tell us about your project
Write to us at hola@wavesstudio.ai and tell us what you need. We are a digital product studio working with businesses in different industries.